Dairy protein demand is booming, but that doesn’t necessarily translate into better milk checks.
As processors ramp up cheese and whey production to capture strong protein markets, growing milk supplies are putting pressure on Class III prices, according to Corey Geiger, lead dairy economist at CoBank. For dairy farmers in cheese-producing regions, beef revenue could help make up the difference.
Whey protein is a big part of that changing market picture. Whey protein isolate and whey protein concentrate 80 — the two leading dairy proteins — now account for 77% of all whey protein production. Even with production of both categories at record highs, prices remain strong.
The demand is having an impact on the protein market. Cheese vats across the U.S. are running full as processors work to keep up with the growing demand for whey. The reason: Cheese and whey production go hand in hand. To produce whey, a facility must make cheese or acquire whey from a cheesemaker.
“In our parents and grandparents’ generation, whey was a byproduct. Cheesemakers the world over almost begged dairy farmers to help them dispose of whey,” Geiger explained. “Dairy farmers often fed liquid whey to baby pigs, and those pigs grew fast because the liquid byproduct of cheesemaking contained some of the most complete amino acids known to humanity, which are the building blocks for protein and muscle. In other occasions, the byproduct of cheesemaking was simply applied to nearby farm fields as it had little value because the technology to extract whey powders hadn’t been mastered yet.”
The industry has come a long way since then. Whey is now a coproduct of cheesemaking, with values equal to or greater than cheese itself. Geiger pointed out that some analysts even argue that, in certain facilities, cheese is becoming the byproduct as processors produce commodity cheese in record volumes to capture the value of the whey stream.
The U.S. cheese story
Investment in U.S. dairy processing is helping drive the increase in cheese production. Multiple cheese and whey facilities have come on line, with the capacity to process 10 million pounds of milk per day or roughly 862,000 pounds of cheddar daily.
According to Geiger, that’s one reason U.S. cheese production has climbed 6.9% compared to just two years ago.
“Then there’s the fact that the U.S. dairy cow herd has climbed by over 350,000 head to reach 9.7 million dairy cows since January 2025,” he added. “While dairy farmers continue to grow the dairy herd to capture premiums in the beef category, the resulting milk needs to find a processing home. It’s found a home in cheese vats.”
With U.S. cheese consumption remaining flat due to slower restaurant traffic, more of that production is finding its way into export markets. Just two years ago, the U.S. exported 6% of its cheese production. By August, that share climbed to nearly 11%.
The U.S. isn’t the only region producing more milk.
Global milk supplies add to picture
The European Union’s milk supply is up 3.1% year to date compared to last year.
“This matters because the EU dairy industry is 1.6 times larger than the U.S.,” Geiger said. “And, when combined with the U.S., these two regions easily represent the world’s top two cheesemakers.”
New Zealand is also adding to global dairy supplies. Milk solids production climbed 2% year over year in September, and milk volumes remain strong.
“That means more dairy products and ingredients will be flowing from the world’s second-largest dairy exporter,” he added.
Milk prices feel the pressure
More milk moving into cheese production is creating different signals across the dairy market, particularly for Class III and Class IV prices, according to Geiger.
In October, Class III slid to $15.16, its lowest point in eight months.
“On the flip side, Class IV climbed to $20.54, buoyed by strong price support for nonfat dry milk,” Geiger said. “That support is largely driven by the fact more milk is headed to cheese vats to make more whey, not the fact that demand for nonfat dry milk is soaring.”
The result was a historic $5.38 spread between Class III and Class IV milk prices.
For dairy farmers in strong cheese-producing regions, Geiger said they will need to rely on beef revenue to cover softer milk revenue in the near term.
He believes the price spread likely represents a high point. December CME futures still project $21 Class IV and $17 Class III, a $4 difference.
Moving into the new year, that spread is expected to narrow to about $2 per cwt. Geiger pointed out that there are some indications EU milk production growth should moderate, which would begin to tighten milk supplies and slow growth in cheese production.