Top Tips: When harvest ends, the real decisions begin

FPFF - Thu Nov 19, 2:30PM CST

Top Tips on a Thursday


Your crops may be in the bin, but the decisions are just getting started. The experts we tapped on this week’s edition of Top Tips tackle everything from why your banker wants bad news early to how firm basis is masking softer futures to what El Niño could mean for Brazil’s soybean crop in the weeks ahead. 

Add in fresh insight on satellite-based yield data and a case for diversifying your farm’s energy sources, and a clear theme emerges: Control what you can control and know your numbers cold.

  • Minimum-price contracts or call option strategies can let farmers protect current price levels on unsold grain.
  • Tight basis for corn and soybeans is cushioning the impact of falling board prices.
  • Plus: Re-ownership of row crops is currently cheaper than storage in many cases.

Lynn Paulson, Bell Bank


“This sounds counterintuitive, but most bankers would rather know bad news first. It really is a partnership. As a bank, we’re only as successful as our customers. So we love good news, but you want to talk to your banker a little bit before a financial situation reaches a critical stage, your options are limited and you get into a corner that has no exit, no off ramp.

“There are very few problems that I’ve encountered over the four and a half decades that I’ve been in banking that couldn’t be solved if addressed early enough — maybe not perfect solutions but ones that keep you in the game.

“As a banker, I see a hundred operations. An operator sees only one. Because of that I can draw some inferences about best practices or offer things that they might want to consider.” 

— Lynn Paulson, senior vice president, Bell State Bank & Trust

ACTION: Schedule a conversation with your banker to review the farm’s finances and plan for the future.

Matt Wiegand, FuturesOne


“We saw trade pancake back to fresh lows for corn and wheat at midweek with aggressive selling after failing to clear nearby resistance Tuesday amid continued outside market weakness in stocks, metals and energies kept pressure in place. Harvest is now virtually complete nationally for row crops, which is helping basis to firm at processors and exporters. We have seen spread action turn a bit weaker for corn, but it has remained solid for soybeans short term, indicating that nearby demand is holding up pretty well. We also have December option expiration on Friday with trade heading toward delivery at the end of next week, which often has trade move to pin a strike price at the settle.

“Short term, the biggest thing for producers to watch is making sure near-term cash flow needs have been met as we head toward the end of the year. Re-ownership of row crops remains cheaper than storage rates in most cases in the short term if bushels need to move and you want to keep upside open. New crop values will need to be watched for seasonal strengths to watch for opportunities to protect margins, especially if fall fertilizer has been applied. If outside markets improve, we could see a sharp relief rally develop.”

— Matt Wiegand, risk management consultant, FuturesOne

ACTION: Fall fuel prices will open the opportunity to cover winter needs into December where we typically see seasonal weakness.

John Zanker, Farmer’s Keeper


“Corn basis has been hanging strong lately as processors struggle to pull supplies away from reluctant sellers. That reluctance is understandable given where prices have been, and that should keep basis tight as we head into the last month of the year. If the basis is sensational in your area, you need to weigh heavily the value of getting some bushels moved. I’m not a big lover of basis contracts and, given shrinking carry and rising interest rates, would prefer a minimum-price type contract with your local buyer.

“Soybean basis has not been as strong as corn, but it’s still firm, and sales should be considered if it’s abnormally strong in your area. Storing the unsold balance into the winter will prove to be a wise decision if growing season problems arise in South America. But if Brazil and Argentina knock out another big crop, it’s going to be difficult to hold a ‘12’ in front of futures. You can lock in current levels and participate in a big South America-led rally via the use of minimum-price contracts or call option strategies.

— John Zanker, senior analyst, Farmer’s Keeper

ACTION: Consider minimum-price contracts for unsold corn and soybeans, and watch for any unfavorable turns in South American weather.

Chase Koopmans, The Grain Ledger Rundown


“Funds have turned betting on lower prices, but not heavily. Corn isn’t stretched the way wheat is. It’s more a question of whether funds want to push their bet bigger heading into South America’s growing season, when weather surprises happen.

“Meanwhile, the cash market barely flinched. Gulf export bids for both corn and beans are running above their three-year averages. Here in the interior, corn bids are better than a year ago in a lot of places as processors work to pry bushels loose from farmers who don’t want to sell at these prices. Ethanol plants are a big part of that. Cheap corn keeps their margins working, so they keep grinding. Ethanol stocks are also at a record, which is the one thing to keep an eye on.

“So while the board fell double digits, the price a lot of farmers can actually get fell less. That’s a big deal if you’re pricing grain, and it’s why it pays to watch your local basis, not just the futures. Weeks like this test patience. The farmers who come out of them in good shape aren’t the ones who guess the headline right. They’re the ones who know their numbers cold: their breakeven, how much is sold, how much is protected and how much is still riding.”

— Chase Koopmans, writer, The Grain Ledger Rundown

ACTION: Know your numbers. Track your breakeven, your sales and your price risk.

Yoav Sharaby, SatYield


“Last month, we questioned whether USDA’s 181.2 bushel-per-acre national corn yield estimate was too high. Last Tuesday’s World Agricultural Supply and Demand Estimates report lowered it to 179.6, close to SatYield’s Nov. 8 satellite-based forecast of 180.5. Soybeans moved in the opposite direction, increasing from 53.1 to 53.3, compared with SatYield’s 53.5.

“The regional differences are particularly interesting. Illinois saw USDA reduce corn yields by 8 bushels and soybeans by 4, while Minnesota moved in the opposite direction, gaining 9 bushels in corn and 5 in soybeans. These states canceled each other’s national yield impact out.

“September’s unusually warm weather may help explain these differences. Late-season heat, particularly warm nights, can affect grain filling and final seed weight, depending on crop maturity and soil moisture. The impact varies significantly by crop and geography: Corn was mostly impaired, while soybeans, which were still in an earlier seed-filling stage, benefited from rains that came with the heat in the western Corn Belt.

“The key takeaway: National averages can conceal substantial regional production differences. Satellite observations, crop phenology and biophysical simulation offer an opportunity to identify these changes earlier, before they appear in official USDA estimates.”

— Yoav Sharaby, crop science team lead, SatYield

ACTION: Watch USDA’s January report, particularly for Iowa and Nebraska, where more complete harvest data could lead to further revisions.

Karen Braun, Zaner Ag Hedge


“Brazil’s soybean crop is entering an important stretch, and El Niño is once again part of the conversation. The last two strong El Niño seasons, 2015-16 and 2023-24, coincided with substantial soybean yield losses in Mato Grosso, Brazil’s top-producing state. But the relationship between El Niño and soybean yields varies considerably across Brazil, and similar historical outcomes don’t necessarily develop under identical weather conditions.

“In examining how the current season compares with those earlier episodes, including planting progress, satellite vegetation readings, regional rainfall patterns and the latest forecast outlooks, there are some disagreements are worth flagging. With Brazil’s earliest soybean harvest potentially beginning in late December, the next several weeks are going to be key in determining production potential for the world’s largest soybean exporter.”

— Karen Braun, chief market analyst, Zaner Ag Hedge

ACTION: Watch Brazil weather patterns closely over the next month and the start of harvest.

Michael Newland, PERC


“For equipment with high annual fuel use, diesel price swings can quickly turn a predictable operating expense into a moving target. While farmers cannot control the price of diesel, they can control how dependent their operations are on any single energy source. 

“Just as producers diversify crops, suppliers and marketing strategies to manage risk, diversifying energy sources can help make fuel costs less vulnerable to volatility in any one market. For instance, adopting propane irrigation engines and propane power generators can reduce farmers’ overall energy spend while providing reliable on-site power that is impervious to electricity and diesel price surges. Many commercial-scale grain-drying operations are using blended air systems to combat natural gas curtailment as well. These systems can instantly switch from natural gas to propane when cost or supply concerns threaten operations. Plus, on-site propane storage allows producers to purchase and store fuel ahead of peak operating periods, helping them better forecast energy expenses.

“The bigger opportunity is to start thinking about fuel decisions in terms of total operating risk rather than simply comparing the price of a gallon of propane with a gallon of diesel. Consider how much fuel an application consumes annually, when that fuel is needed, what storage is available and what an unexpected price spike or supply disruption could mean during a critical window. Moving the right applications away from diesel can help producers create a more resilient energy portfolio without asking them to accomplish the work with less energy.”

— Michael Newland, director of agriculture business development, Propane Education & Research Council 

ACTION: For farms where uptime is essential, changing the fuel can sometimes be a more practical risk-management strategy than trying to use less of it.

Don Dawson, independent trader


“One of the most expensive mistakes futures traders make is believing a market has fallen too far to sell short. After a prolonged decline, prices may appear attractive, tempting traders to anticipate a bottom rather than follow the prevailing trend. However, markets are not obligated to reverse simply because prices seem historically low. Chicago wheat futures offer another example of why trading with the trend, rather than trying to predict a reversal, deserves consideration.

“Several fundamentals continue to weigh on wheat prices. Renewed hopes for peace negotiations between Russia and Ukraine, along with improving prospects for Black Sea grain shipments, could reduce some of the geopolitical risk premium, although disruptions remain a concern. Meanwhile, the global wheat supply cycle is shifting. Northern Hemisphere producers have largely completed their harvests and are planting winter wheat, while Southern Hemisphere countries, including Argentina and Australia, are entering their harvest season. This seasonal transition adds export supplies to an already competitive global market, creating further headwinds for wheat prices. Weak U.S. export prospects are adding to those concerns. The technical trend is bearish, and it’s possible wheat futures can continue even lower.”

Don Dawson, independent trader & Barchart contributor

ACTION: Watch May 2027 Chicago wheat futures. It will likely take a close above $6.46 to signal a trend change.

Gabrielle Bourret-Sicotte, Treefera


“Brazil’s soybean planting has progressed relatively well despite uneven rainfall. The crop was 80% planted as of a week ago, ahead of the 70% historical average, according to consultant Safras & Mercado. Although planting is ahead of last year, conditions vary considerably across growing regions. Rainfall has been uneven across the Cerrado, with deficits in parts of Mato Grosso and excessive rain in southern Brazil. Some fields in Maranhão, Tocantins, Piauí and Bahia may need replanting.

“Planting progress provides an important starting point, but subsequent weather and crop development will determine how much of that production potential reaches harvest. Treefera recently updated its forecast for Brazil’s 2026-27 soybean crop to 178.5 million metric tons (MMT), down from 183.5 MMT previously. By comparison, USDA’s and CONAB’s estimates are 186 MMT and 181.3 MMT, respectively. Our update captures contrasting regional conditions, including Paraná’s wettest season start in our record, which extends back to 1990, and a drier start in Mato Grosso.

“The season remains early, and the range of potential outcomes is still wide. We’re tracking how those regional patterns evolve, particularly as crops approach flowering in Mato Grosso. The next stages of development will help establish whether early moisture conditions translate into meaningful effects on yield.”

— Gabrielle Bourret-Sicotte, head of customer solutions, Treefera

ACTION: Watch for any adverse weather in South American and for potential price rallies.